Send to a friend
Pin It
back to search results

Lucky Duck Cottage in Cayuga Lake

Cayuga Lake House Rental Picture Cayuga Lake House Vacation Rental Picture House in Cayuga Lake, New York Picture Cayuga Lake Vacation House for Rent Picture House Rental in Cayuga Lake Picture Cayuga Lake House Lodging Picture House in Cayuga Lake Rental Picture Rental House in Cayuga Lake, New York Picture

vacation rental description

Single family lakehouse on the west shore of Cayuga Lake.  Ideal
location about 3 miles from downtown Ithaca and just south of Ithaca
Yacht Club.  Heavily wooded 1.5+ acre lot providing gorgeous views
and privacy.  Drive to the door of the house via paved driveway.
Three bedrooms in main house, including huge master.

Separate bunkhouse with bunk beds. Two full baths, Jacuzzi tub,
new fully equipped kitchen and new master bath. Large living room
and eat in kitchen.

We treat this like a second home and it is maintained as such. It
is warm and inviting, with some of the best vistas on the lake; a
one of a kind location.

Occupancy is limited to 6 people total, non-smokers; no pets are

vacation rental location

property availability

  • dates with deals
  • unavailable dates

Last modified on 05-3-2014 at 8:49 PM.

email owner view full calendar

John Longstreet 972-517-1387

house rental amenities

Outdoor Gas Grill, all new kitchen appliances, sound system with CD player, XM radio and outside speakers, cable TV with DVD and VCR, high speed wireless Internet, boathouse with use of 2 kayaks, patio on the lake adjacent to the boathouse, 2 outdoor fire pits, picnic table, ping pong table, horse shoe pit, and new washer and dryer.  Towels and linens  provided.

activities and attractions in Cayuga Lake Finger Lakes

Swimming and kayaking in beautiful Lake Cayuga; dock with swim ladder. Seven minute drive to downtown Ithaca. Five minute drive to: Cass Park, The Hanger Theater, Taughannock Park and Taughannock Falls.  Short walk to Glenwood Pines Restaurant. Ten to fifteen minute drive to the Cayuga Wine Trail. Fifteen minutes from Cornell.

vacation rental rates

Lucky Duck Cottage rents by the week (six nights)only, with the exception of graduation and reunion weekends, at the rate of $2400.00 per six-night week.

10:00am Saturday check-in to Noon Friday check-out.
50% non-refundable deposit is required at the time the reservation is made; the balance (also non-refundable) is due 30 days before taking possession.

Graduation & Reunion Weekends: $1000 per night (3 night minimum).
Security Deposit of $500.00 due 30 days before taking possession; will be refunded providing no damage is done to the property or its
contents, and the property is clean and in the same condition as it
was in at check-in time.  A signed rental agreement is required.

email owner

John Longstreet 972-517-1387

contact owner

please fill in the form below to inquire about this rental.


  • owner John Longstreet
  • phone 972-517-1387

When you book a vacation rental on any of our websites, we want you to experience a carefree vacation. Learn More

payment methods

Owner has not provided their accepted payment methods

Prior to paying a reservation deposit, always verify payment instructions by calling the phone number displayed on this listing page. By contacting the owner directly and paying by an approved method - credit card, paypal, check or bank transfer - your reservation payment will be protected up to $1,000.

Learn more in our Security Center

Cayuga Lake house photos at a glance

Cayuga Lake House Rental Picture
House in Cayuga Lake, New York Picture
House Rental in Cayuga Lake Picture
House in Cayuga Lake Rental Picture
Cayuga Lake House Vacation Rental Picture
Cayuga Lake Vacation House for Rent Picture
Cayuga Lake House Lodging Picture
Rental House in Cayuga Lake, New York Picture

email owner

John Longstreet 972-517-1387

traveler reviews for this cayuga lake house rental

Cornell Graduation Weekend 2013

Review submitted: June 13, 2013   Date of arrival: May 23, 2013

We thoroughly enjoyed our long weekend at Lucky Duck Cottage (despite unseasonably cold late spring weather). This is a vacation home, not just a rental property. It's proximity to Ithaca (and Cornell) made the location ideal to have friends visit and spend time with us during the weekend (vs. where they were staying which was much further away). Our fourteen year old son and his friend quickly embraced having their own place -- the bunkhouse. We concluded the weekend hosting a post graduation party for our graduating daughter, her fellow graduate friends and their families. The outdoor grill, fire pit, ping pong table, horseshoe pits and the available extra tables and chairs contributed significantly to the party's success! We've already referred families of future graduates to the Lucky Duck Cottage.

Helpful votes: 1 / 1


Lucky Duck

Review submitted: July 9, 2012   Date of arrival: June 16, 2012

We recently spent a week at Lucky Duck and had a wonderful time. It is a lovely home, very clean and conveniently located. You are 10 minutes away from all of the conveniences of Ithaca, but when you get back to Lucky Duck, you feel very remote, quiet and relaxed. The home is also located close to some good hiking areas and state parks as well as some very nice wineries. The owners are very easy to deal with and very responsive and seem to have lots of items on hand in the event you forget something. We all had a great time!

Helpful votes: 0 / 0


Ludky Duck Graduation Weekend 2012

Review submitted: June 18, 2012   Date of arrival: May 22, 2012

Three families shared this lovely home for our daughters' Cornell graduation. The weather was perfect, home in very clean condition, and met all our needs. There was laughter around the firepit each evening and days spent on the lake soaking in the beauty of Lake Cayuga. The home is convenient to Wegman's as well as Cornell University. Horseshoes and pingpong were available for non-lake recreation and the bass caught by our son was enjoyed by all on our last evening. The kitchen met all our cooking needs and there was plenty of hot water for showering our group. The bunkhouse was perfect for our teen boys. The only criticism would be that the trek down the stairs to the lake is a haul and unsafe for young children to maneuver alone. We count ourselves lucky for being able to spend time at the Lucky Duck cabin!

Recommended for: adventure seekers, families with teenagers

Helpful votes: 0 / 0


Reviews are the subjective opinions of travelers and not of, Inc.

email owner see all reviews (3/4) write a review

John Longstreet 972-517-1387

Cayuga Lake vacation rental

This vacation rental has been listed since 12/30/2006.

Page views: 15 this month – 1397 this year – 24771 since listed

View Another Cayuga Lake Vacation House Rental