Send to a friend
Pin It
back to search results

Forever Red: where wine trails and wildlife converge in Cayuga Lake

Cayuga Lake Cottage Rental Picture Cayuga Lake Cottage Vacation Rental Picture Cottage in Cayuga Lake, New York Picture Cayuga Lake Vacation Cottage for Rent Picture Cottage Rental in Cayuga Lake Picture Cayuga Lake Cottage Lodging Picture Cottage in Cayuga Lake Rental Picture Rental Cottage in Cayuga Lake, New York Picture

vacation rental description

Furnished 3 bedroom (2 queen and 1 double), year round, ranch style
house with 75 feet of lake front on north west shore of Cayuga Lake. Great house to settle in to for your vacation, and use as a home base to explore the Finger Lakes Region. The cottage offers convenience whether you want to take advantage of
great fishing, boating and swimming from the back yard, enjoy beautiful sunrises and
peaceful sunsets or explore the Finger Lakes Region. Living room, sunroom and master bedroom have view of lake. First floor includes fully equipped kitchen (coffee pot,, toaster, microwave,waffle iron, dishwasher), living room with pine floor and stone fireplace, sunroom,master bedroom (with queen size platform bed with memory foam mattress),and walk out french doors to deck overlooking lake. Two additional bedrooms (queen and double bed). Basement includes washer/dryer and paritally finished rec room with sliding glass door with view of the lake and lake access. Deck furnished with patio furniture and grill (renter to provide propane).

vacation rental location

property availability

  • dates with deals
  • unavailable dates

Last modified on 04-17-2014 at 8:44 AM.

email owner view full calendar

Jennifer Marshall 607-279-3653

cottage rental amenities

Working fireplace (you will need to bring your own wood)
Fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher
Internet access
Standard Cable TV with 2 televisions
CD/DVD player
Deck Furniture
Gas Grill (renter to provide propane)
2 kayaks (use at own risk, renter to provide life vests fitted to them)
3 window A/C
PS 2 (playstation games not included)
Memory foam mattress in master bedroom
Blankets and pillows for 3 beds and bath towels, PLEASE BRING SHEETS AND PILLOW CASES

activities and attractions in Cayuga Lake Finger Lakes

The setting is beautiful any time of year. Magnificent spring brings
bird migration (minutes from Montezuma Wildlife Refuge), summer offers lake activities, fall brings colorful foliage and wine tours, while winter offers ice fishing and stillness. 

Gorgeous sunrises, peaceful sunsets and solace occur all year round.

Wine trails, shopping, dining and the historical city of Seneca Falls are all minutes away!

Be sure to visit:

Wine Trails,

Waterloo Outlet stores,

Fishing, boating, and hiking
Montezuma Wildlife Refuge, Cayuga Lake State Park,

Miniature golf, Ice cream, Restaurants,


Explore nearby cites/towns:


We are located near several colleges and universities including:

NY Chiropractic School
Wells College
Hobart William Smith
Syracuse University
50 minutes from Cornell University and Ithaca College

vacation rental rates

Our rates are $1350.  Weekend rates are $500 (for two nights). Holidays will include extra charge. Fifty percent of the total charge is due at the time the reservation is made, with the  balance of the rent and a security deposit of $400.00 paidat least 30 days prior to arrival. There will be a twenty-five dollar ($25.00), charge for for allreturned checks. Security deposit will be returned to Tenant 14 days after departure upon approval of Owner.

CANCELLATION: All requests for cancellation must be submitted in writing. Cancellation will be honored and deposit money returned if, and only if, property
is re-rented for the  same time period and rent. Otherwise all terms of this agreement will remain in full force and effect.

Your security deposit will be refunded. We do not have daily housekeeping services.  We can accept Visa or Mastercard via paypal with an addtional service charge. We accept checks only when there is advanced notice of arrival.

Check in is at 4 pm and check out is at 11 am.  

email owner

Jennifer Marshall 607-279-3653

contact owner

please fill in the form below to inquire about this rental.


  • owner Jennifer Marshall
  • phone 607-279-3653

When you book a vacation rental on any of our websites, we want you to experience a carefree vacation. Learn More

accepted payment methods


Prior to paying a reservation deposit, always verify payment instructions by calling the phone number displayed on this listing page. By contacting the owner directly and paying by an approved method - credit card, paypal, check or bank transfer - your reservation payment will be protected up to $1,000.

Learn more in our Security Center
Top things to do in Cayuga Lake
  • Boat and Fish
  • Wineries
  • Shopping
  • Historical Sites
  • Relaxation
Top things to do on a budget
  • Float and relax on lake
  • kayak
  • Birding (we are next to Montezuma Bird Refuge)
  • Sit on the deck and read a great book
  • Walk to Cayuga State Park down the road

Jennifer Marshall , owner

Cayuga Lake cottage photos at a glance

Cayuga Lake Cottage Rental Picture
Cottage in Cayuga Lake, New York Picture
Cottage Rental in Cayuga Lake Picture
Cottage in Cayuga Lake Rental Picture
Cayuga Lake Cottage Vacation Rental Picture
Cayuga Lake Vacation Cottage for Rent Picture
Cayuga Lake Cottage Lodging Picture
Rental Cottage in Cayuga Lake, New York Picture

email owner

Jennifer Marshall 607-279-3653

traveler reviews for this cayuga lake cottage rental

Guest Comment entered by owner

Excerpts from the guest book

Review submitted: October 14, 2013   Date of arrival: September 21, 2013

Pure delight when we got in and looked over this most comforting and spectacular home....
Slept in, head a leisurely breakfast, then read and lolled til nearly 11. Went to Rose Hill Mansion, toured and visited the tasting room next door. Went to Fox Run Winery, bought a mix of wines, found Wegmans and brought food home for dinner.

...went to Watkins Glen and walked up the Gorge trail- gorgeous, hahaha...
...sipped ruby port, looked at the waning moon....
..went to Sonnenburg Mansion and gardens...marvelous place.
...LIt the fire outside and the trhee of us polished off a bottle of white wine.
...went to Corning Museum of Glass...grand fun, Came home...looked at stars, moonrise, slept well.
...drove to Taughannock Falls State Park, visited the Women's Rights National Historical Park, strolled the stores in Seneca Falls...went to Montezuma National Wildlife Refuge- lots of Canada Geese, snow goose and then Montezuma Winery to taste meads....went in the kayaks- lake smooth little wind. Memorable vacation.

Helpful votes: 1 / 1

Guest Comment entered by owner

What a lovely cottage

Review submitted: October 14, 2013   Date of arrival: August 10, 2013

What a lovely cottage you have here at Forever Red! My husband, stepson and I thoroughly enjoyed our stay and are leaving with many fond memories. The three of us sat around the fireplace each evening telling stories and talking...something we don't tend to do at home at least not without electronics! I checked out all the antique shops I could find and visited the Seneca Falls Historical Society. We rented a fishing boat for the week at Cayuga General Store, and the boys caught several fish (pike). My stepson and I had some good laughs together as he navigated the Kayak and I used the extra paddle to follow him in the inner tube. We only wish our stay was longer. Thank you for a such a wonderful space that you obviously care greatly for!

Helpful votes: 0 / 0

Guest Comment entered by owner

How can I express how much we enjoy our stay

Review submitted: October 14, 2013   Date of arrival: August 3, 2013

How can I express how much we enjoy our stay at your cottage each year! The lake is wonderful and I find all the inspiration I need in the farm markets! I always leave wishing I had booked two weeks! Thank you for being a gracious host and sharing your perfect getaway "Forever Red"! We hope to be back next year!

Helpful votes: 0 / 0


Reviews are the subjective opinions of travelers and not of, Inc.

email owner see all reviews (3/32) write a review

Jennifer Marshall 607-279-3653

Cayuga Lake vacation rental

This vacation rental has been listed since 09/7/2007.

Page views: 215 this month – 936 this year – 24281 since listed

View Another Cayuga Lake Vacation House Rental