Send to a friend
Pin It
back to search results

Three Sisters in Keuka Lake

Keuka Lake House Rental Picture Keuka Lake House Vacation Rental Picture House in Keuka Lake, New York Picture Keuka Lake Vacation House for Rent Picture House Rental in Keuka Lake Picture Keuka Lake House Lodging Picture House in Keuka Lake Rental Picture Rental House in Keuka Lake, New York Picture

vacation rental description

Excellent views of the Bluff in this completely redone original cottage 1890's, the 12x30 enclosed front porch is right on the water with a table for 6 and there is an upper open porch off the master bedroom which features a queen size bed.

The second bedroom has a futon/double bunk bed and another double bed and kids just love the loft( 3rd bedroom) which also has a double bed, in addition there is a pull-out couch in the living room and a pull-out on the front porch.

All of the windows are brand new with custom Victorian moldings and there is a great wraparound deck for your vacation enjoyment. We have 100 ft of lake frontage which includes a great walk-in beach area of approx 35 ft. In the beach area you will find a fire-pit as well as a sandbox for the little ones and a kayak for the bigger ones. Three Sisters is right next door to the Keuka Yacht club and has a very private setting for your vacation pleasure

The Town of Pulteney (about 2 miles) has a playground,basketball and tennis courts

vacation rental location

property availability

  • dates with deals
  • unavailable dates

Last modified on 08-16-2014 at 4:24 PM.

email owner view full calendar

Ken Shares

house rental amenities

The kitchen has a gas stove ,new countertops,new flooring and all of the  amenities you could need including a coffeemaker,microwave,toaster,blender,pots/pans,silverware ,knife block,wine glasses,spices,tongs,steak knives, and so on.

Just added a wonderful outdoor Cape-Cod style shower with hot and cold water and a propane gas fireplace in the living room

 Three Sisters provides a charcoal grill and an outdoor firepit. There is  a 9x9 poly- float  to swim to and relax on out in front of the cottage and a boat slip which can moor up to a 26 foot boat as well as another  45' of dock at the edge of a marvelous walk in beach area. We have a picnic table for outdoor dining and a kayak for your use as well.

There is a boat launch/grocery/gas/bait shop(Jake's) within walking distance and parking at the cottage is limited to three cars. We do however have a farm(a mile away) where you may store your trailer for $50/week

We have a very cozy cottage with basic cable VCR/DVDand internet services for your use. Three Sisters has public water but is on septic so we ask that you conserve resources.

activities and attractions in Keuka Lake Finger Lakes

We are halfway between Branchport(N) and Hammondsport(S) which has many nice restaurants and shops,Dr Frank's winery is about a mile or so up the road as well Keuka Brewery ,Heron Hill and Bully Hill Winery.

the fishing is great and there are even charters at Jake's launch(less than a mile South) and there is dining on the lake as well

if you travel to PennYan(15miles) they have Keuka carts(go carts), ice cream shops,grocery stores,taverns and stands where you can find local produce and fruit pies!

 there are tennis courts and a playground up in the Town of Pulteney next to town hall and in Penn Yan there is a golf course

 Hammondsport is a quaint town and has a number of restaurants/pubs a grocery, many small shops and a post office,  a laundramat and  of course ice cream!

vacation rental rates

Peak Summer Rates:is June 1 2010-Sept 2010  

Weekly Rate Breakdown:

6/21-6/28/14: $1,800

6/28-7/5/14: $2,400

7/5-7/12/14: $2,000

7/12-7/19/14: $2,000

7/19-7/26/14: $2,400

7/26-8/2/14: $2,400

8/2-8/9/14: $2,400

8/9-8/16/14: $2,400

8/16-8/23/14: $2,400

8/23-8/30/14: $2,000

8/30-9/6/14: $1,800

Off Season (Spring and Fall)

$900 for a 3 night package.

Ask us about special monthly rates

Additional Fees: $250 Refundable Secuity Deposit


email owner

Ken Shares

contact owner

please fill in the form below to inquire about this rental.


  • owner Ken Shares
  • 2nd phone 585-924-3913

When you book a vacation rental on any of our websites, we want you to experience a carefree vacation. Learn More

accepted payment methods


Prior to paying a reservation deposit, always verify payment instructions by calling the phone number displayed on this listing page. By contacting the owner directly and paying by an approved method - credit card, paypal, check or bank transfer - your reservation payment will be protected up to $1,000.

Learn more in our Security Center
Top things to do in Keuka Lake
  • Wineries
  • Keuka State Park
  • Fishing
  • hanging out at the beach
  • reading
Top things to do on a budget
  • cookouts
  • hiking/biking
  • tennis/playground in Pulteney
  • puzzles
  • board games
Top things to do with a family
  • swimming
  • boating
  • campfires and s'mores
  • Keuka Go-carts
  • fishing

Ken Shares , owner

Keuka Lake house photos at a glance

Keuka Lake House Rental Picture
House in Keuka Lake, New York Picture
House Rental in Keuka Lake Picture
House in Keuka Lake Rental Picture
Keuka Lake House Vacation Rental Picture
Keuka Lake Vacation House for Rent Picture
Keuka Lake House Lodging Picture
Rental House in Keuka Lake, New York Picture

email owner

Ken Shares

traveler reviews for this keuka lake house rental

Vintage charm and gorgeous decks!

Review submitted: September 14, 2013   Date of arrival: August 10, 2013

When my husband and I were looking for cottage on Keuka lake, we wanted something with character and that also had great access to the water.

Three Sisters delivered admirably. Ken, the owner, was very easy to work with and answered questions promptly via email or phone prior to our arrival. When we arrived, the cottage was in good condition for us to start our vacation. One suggestion: a sheet explaining a few things like how to operate the gas fireplace, etc would be so helpful. Cell service can be spotty in this area. The photos included with the listing were accurate and helpful.

The property sits adjacent to the Keuka Yacht Club, so in the evening, when they have all gone home it is very quiet. We liked that the cottage was not crammed right next to neighboring house on the other side. Plenty of space.

The decks are phenomenal! They are right over the water, allowing you to jump in (there's also a spot to wade in - but bring shoes - it's rocky!). Lots of room to spread out. There is also an outdoor shower and an upper deck off the master bedroom.

Inside was old-school charming. Cozy, comfortable and had all the necessities. Nothing fancy here - but we didn't want fancy. We spent the most time on the screened porch overlooking the deck and the lake. Amazing. The beds are adequate. Probably should be replaced fairly soon, but they were fine. Again, we viewed this as a cottage vacation from the old days where there were some quirks, rather than a luxury resort where every whim is granted.

As the previous review mentioned, there is no A/C. We were lucky and had a mild week so were fine with fans.

The house is reached by going down stairs (typical for many of the cottages on Keuka). The stairs here were in good condition and the parking easily held 3 cars. Those with limited mobility probably would have difficulties here.

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at the "Three Sisters"!

Recommended for: families with young children, families with teenagers, girls getaway, sight seeing, romantic getaway

Helpful votes: 1 / 1


Great Fun

Review submitted: August 13, 2012   Date of arrival: August 14, 2011

We stayed there last summer and had a blast. My kids said it is the best vacation we have ever taken and we have been to Disney World and the Grand Canyon. They enjoyed it better than those places. It was great fun boating on the lake! I would recommend bringing a portable air condition during the hottest part of the summer. That was the only draw back. It was unseasonably hot when we went and it was uncomfortable at night because of the heat. Our actual stay was July 17, 2011 but it was saying it was too far in the past.

Helpful votes: 1 / 1


Reviews are the subjective opinions of travelers and not of, Inc.

email owner write a review

Ken Shares

Keuka Lake vacation rental

This vacation rental has been listed since 01/5/2010.

Page views: 10 this month – 2050 this year – 20668 since listed

View Another Keuka Lake Vacation House Rental