Send to a friend
Pin It
back to search results

Waterfront Island Cottage, Perfect for fishing/boating in Indian Lake

Indian Lake House Rental Picture Indian Lake House Vacation Rental Picture House in Indian Lake, Ohio Picture Indian Lake Vacation House for Rent Picture House Rental in Indian Lake Picture Indian Lake House Lodging Picture House in Indian Lake Rental Picture Rental House in Indian Lake, Ohio Picture

vacation rental description

Surrounded by Indian Lake with beautiful views of water and wooded island. It is located in a beautiful wooded landscape that is a country setting. This is the perfect place to fish and boat with the fishing preserve just around the corner and the open water for boating only a few feet away.  There is a covered area at dock and a long pier on the property for your convenience in docking your boat.  The cottage has been remodeled and has all the newer amenities to make your stay comfortable and memorable.  The yard is large with nice mature trees, an enclosed back porch, grill, picnic table, fire ring and of course the water's edge.  There are water views both from the front and back since you are on an island with only 5 houses to the end. 

  • 2 Bedrooms with Queen size beds
  • 1 Bedroom with Full size bed
  • 1 Sofa/Bed with Full size bed
  • 3 Couches in Living Room, 2 full size, 1 loveseat

The cottage has been recently remodeled with a new furnace and central air conditioning.  A second full bath added in 2014.

Sorry but no pets allowed.

vacation rental location

property availability

  • dates with deals
  • unavailable dates

Last modified on 07-11-2014 at 7:51 PM.

email owner view full calendar

Elaine K. Conley 937-372-3341

house rental amenities


  • 3 Bedrooms *see below for linen instructions
  • 2 Baths, 1 with linen closet
  • New Furnace and central Air Conditioning
  • Fully Equipped Kitchen with dishwasher, microwave, toaster oven and all cooking and eating utensils
  • Screened in back porch with comfortable furniture
  • Washer/Dryer
  • TV and DVD player
  • Covered parking
  • Long private pier and dock to accomodate 2 boats
  • Charcoal grill and picnic table
  • Lakeside
  • Firepit with covered fishing area and furniture

If you want to rent a boat there are places to rent either pontoon or ski boats with daily or weekly rentals.  The boats are very nice and the people are friendly.

*The kitchen linens are provided but you will need to bring sheets/pillow cases for 2 queen beds and 1 full bed along with towels for bathing and swimming.  There are blankets and comforters for the beds and couches.  There is sofa bed is in the living room which is also a full size bed.

activities and attractions in Indian Lake Ohio

This is a very large lake that has regular fishing tournaments, many restaurants with pull up areas for boats, skiing areas along with many swimming and fishing spots.  There is a very large preserve close to the cottage that is home to much wildlife, including eagles in the last 2 years.  A great place to explore for turtles and birds.  In the fall there are many duck hunting activities and with all the wooded area it is a beautiful place to enjoy the Ohio fall colors and stunning sunsets all year round.

Each holiday is celebrated with community actvities from spectacular fireworks on the 4th of July to the "Ring of Fire" over Labor Day weekend.  Many more activities are throughout the year and even into the winter the ice skating and fishing are enjoyable.  There are snowmobiles on the lake when the water freezes in addition to ice skating.

There are 2 towns close by and a new flea market to make shopping close and convenient and exploring the treasures of the lake.  On the way around the lake stop at the go cart tracks for a spin and the arcade to play electronic games the whole family can enjoy.

A short distance drive to these additional activities:  Ohio Caverns, Marmon Valley Farms with several activities(including horseback riding) and Mad River Moutain Skiing. 




vacation rental rates

Peak Season:  After Memorial Day weekend to Labor Day


Sorry but no rentals less than full week during peak season

Non Peak Season:  After Labor Day to Memorial Day

$475.00  One week  2 NIGHT MINIMUM

$300.00 Weekends (----2 nights minimum) each additional night $125.00

Deposit of $200.00 to hold within 7 days of booking with rent due 60 days prior to arrival.  Cancellations 30 days prior to arrival for a complete refund and within 30 days a refund if property is rerented.  The deposit is not applied to the rent and is refunded within 2 weeks of departure provided no damage to property, keys are returned to proper place, and house is cleaned to condition upon arrival.

We do not provide cleaning unless you request for an additional $75.00 but if you clean to condition upon your arrival no fee is charged.  The cottage is checked and a fee will be deducted if the cleaning is not adequate.

Payment methods:  personal check, Master Card, Visa, American Express

Sorry but not pets allowed

email owner

Elaine K. Conley 937-372-3341

contact owner

please fill in the form below to inquire about this rental.


  • owner Elaine K. Conley
  • phone 937-372-3341
  • 2nd phone 937-372-5132

When you book a vacation rental on any of our websites, we want you to experience a carefree vacation. Learn More

accepted payment methods

credit card

Prior to paying a reservation deposit, always verify payment instructions by calling the phone number displayed on this listing page. By contacting the owner directly and paying by an approved method - credit card, paypal, check or bank transfer - your reservation payment will be protected up to $1,000.

Learn more in our Security Center
Top things to do in Indian Lake
  • Boating
  • Fishing
  • Go carts
  • Flea Market
  • Snow mobiling/Ice Skating
Top things to do on a budget
  • Picnicing
  • Swimming at Beach
  • Biking
  • Parks
  • Amish Crafts/Farm Markets
Top things to do with a family
  • Boating/fishing/swimming
  • Picnic
  • Go carts
  • Restaurants on water with boat docking
  • Ohio Caverns & Horseback riding (Marmon Valley) just 20 miles

Elaine K. Conley , owner

Indian Lake house photos at a glance

Indian Lake House Rental Picture
House in Indian Lake, Ohio Picture
House Rental in Indian Lake Picture
House in Indian Lake Rental Picture
Indian Lake House Vacation Rental Picture
Indian Lake Vacation House for Rent Picture
Indian Lake House Lodging Picture
Rental House in Indian Lake, Ohio Picture

email owner

Elaine K. Conley 937-372-3341

traveler reviews for this indian lake house rental

waterfront Island Cottage

Review submitted: June 21, 2013   Date of arrival: June 14, 2013

Loved this cottage! Very relaxing and loved being in the lagoon close to the mouth of the big lake. The kids had so much fun fishing and playing in the backyard. Meet one of the neighbor's who took us on a boat ride twice. Couldn't have asked for nicer neighbor's. Hoping to make this a family tradition and would love to come back to this cottage.

Recommended for: age 55+, families with young children, people with disabilities, romantic getaway

Owners response: Thanks and so glad you enjoyed your vacation. We would welcome you back and also find our neighbors friendly and have a fun time when we are there.

Helpful votes: 2 / 2


Relaxing week at the Lake

Review submitted: March 30, 2012   Date of arrival: June 13, 2011

What a great little cottage! This place is so charming. We arrived to find a vintage cottage decorated in period accessories straight from our childhood. Three nicely furnished bedrooms (2 with queen size beds), a nice cozy living room with a view of the inlet, a spacious kitchen with a dishwasher and a charming little screened porch at the back complete with gas grill. The cottage is off the main lake down a short inlet and across from an uninhabited island full of birds. Large trees in the back yard with the water only a short walk from the back door. Nice little shelter at dockside lets you lean back and put up your feet in the shade. The dock is well cared for and there is even a fire pit near the water for those sunset campfires we love so much. Easy access to the main lake and a fabulous wildlife sanctuary just around the corner that we boated to several times during our stay. We heard rumors of eagles, but we didn't see any ourselves. We did see plenty of grey Herons, though.

The neighborhood is mostly permanent residents, and we were warmly greeted by several folks when we took our evening walks to a nearby bridge and boat launch. Plenty of attractions nearby by boat: Beaches, restaurants, a boat-up McDonalds in Russels Point, and a bizarre little restaurant called the Tiltin' Hilton you shouldn't miss. A grocery store is only about 10 minutes away. We had a wonderfully relaxing time and the rental rate was very reasonable. Highly recommended. A++

Recommended for: age 55+, families with young children, families with teenagers, romantic getaway

Owners response: It is a pleasure to know that others have enjoyed the cottage and surroundings. We hope to make the vacation a great experience and memorable for all the family.

Helpful votes: 15 / 15


Reviews are the subjective opinions of travelers and not of, Inc.

email owner write a review

Elaine K. Conley 937-372-3341

Indian Lake vacation rental

This vacation rental has been listed since 03/28/2012.

Page views: 408 this month – 3760 this year – 12354 since listed

View Another Indian Lake Vacation House Rental