Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, New York
Fire Island, New York Vacation Rentals and Tourism
Fire Island is where bored, overworked city dwellers (and people from all over the world for that matter) come to play! But once you’ve made it to the beaches of New York, where do you stay? Your answer is Fire Island vacation rentals. Imagine a day spent out in the sun, surfing or relaxing, an evening spent dining in New York’s finest restaurants and mingling with friends and family, and late nights spent letting loose in the night club or clubs of your choice! Fire Island summer beach vacations can be as calm or exciting as you want; that’s what makes them so unique. And luckily, you can begin planning your trip today – your options for Fire Island lodging fill the spectrum. Whether you’re looking for Fire Island pet friendly rentals or a honeymoon suite, you can find it right here.
- What more help planning your vacation? Read our full Fire Island Travel Guide!
When visiting the tourist hot spot, make sure to take a nature tour through the beautiful Sunken Forest, and enjoy the stunning view of the New York City skyline from the top of the historic Fire Island Lighthouse. The bottom line, however, is you can do as much or as little as you want. By staying in a Fire Island waterfront vacation home rental, you will have easy access to the beach, so a day of heavenly leisure, fun activity, or both, will be just steps away.
A Fire Island luxury vacation is within reach thanks to all the Fire Island vacation rentals found here. You can easily call one of the gorgeous Fire Island luxury oceanfront vacation house rentals your next home away from home, even if you happen to be on a strict budget! Unlike hotels, vacation homes come in all varieties and are available for vacationers of all incomes.
Fire Island Vacation Rental Deals
Plenty of discounted Fire Island vacation rentals are vying to be your next home away from home! Take your pick of spacious, yet cheap Fire Island beach houses, roomy and luxurious villas, and sizable – but reasonably priced – town homes. No matter what budget you’re working with or who you’re traveling with, we’re positive that you’ll find a low-cost Fire Island rental for your next vacation. Since you’ll be saving so much money with our Fire Island vacation rental deals that you can afford to explore every inch of the island. Among the beaches and seafood, don't miss out on the Sunken Forest for colorful birds, turtles, and twisted trees. And most of all – don’t miss out on last minute deals on Fire Island beach rentals!
Sights and tours to see
Sunken Forest
Fire Island Lighthouse
more destinations
Check out more areas which feature homes, villas, cabins, cottages, or condos.
-
Pizza & Wine
($50)
- bedrooms 4
- community Kismet
- rental type House
- sleeps 8
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$1,800
- $3,500
/wk
$10,000 - $13,000 /mth
- bedrooms 4
- community Seaview
- rental type House
owner badge
- sleeps 10
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$1,800
- $3,500
/wk
- bedrooms 5
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 12
- baths 3
- rates (USD)
$2,500
- $7,000
/wk
- bedrooms 2
- community Atlantique
- rental type House
- sleeps 4
- baths 1½
- rates (USD)
$2,000
- $2,500
/wk
- bedrooms 3
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 6
- baths 1½
- rates (USD)
$1,200
- $2,600
/wk
$12,000 - $12,000 /mth
- bedrooms 4
- community Robbins Rest
- rental type House
owner badge
- sleeps 8
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$516
- $1,000
/nt
$3,100 - $5,000 /wk
- bedrooms 5
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 12
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$2,000
- $4,500
/wk
$14,000 - $16,000 /mth
- bedrooms 6
- community ~*~Ocean Bay Park~*~
- rental type House
owner badge
- sleeps 12
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$5,000
- $7,000
/wk
$20,000 - $30,000 /mth
- bedrooms 3
- community Fair Harbor
- rental type House
- sleeps 6
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$3,000
- $3,000
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Davis Park
- rental type House
owner badge
- sleeps 7
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$2,900
- $4,000
/wk
$10,000 - $12,000 /mth
- bedrooms 5
- community ~*~Ocean Bay Park~*~
- rental type House
- sleeps 14
- baths 3
- rates (USD)
$5,000
- $8,000
/wk
- bedrooms 5
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 13
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$4,000
- $5,500
/wk
- bedrooms 2
- community Davis Park
- rental type House
owner badge
- sleeps 4
- baths 1½
- rates (USD)
$300
- $400
/nt
$2,000 - $2,000 /wk
$8,000 - $8,000 /mth
- bedrooms 2
- community
- rental type Cottage
- sleeps 5
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$2,000
- $2,200
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Robbins Rest
- rental type House
- sleeps 8
- baths 1½
- rates (USD)
$300
- $450
/nt
$2,000 - $3,000 /wk
$8,000 - $12,000 /mth
- bedrooms 4
- community ~*~Ocean Bay Park~*~
- rental type House
owner badge
- sleeps 12
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$2,750
- $5,000
/wk
$10,000 - $16,000 /mth
- bedrooms 5
- community Kismet
- rental type House
- sleeps 12
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$2,750
- $5,125
/wk
$15,000 - $25,000 /mth
- bedrooms 2
- community Davis Park
- rental type Cottage
- sleeps 5
- baths 1½
- rates (USD)
$1,600
- $2,150
/wk
- bedrooms 3
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 6
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$2,500
- $5,500
/wk
$8,000 - $18,000 /mth
- bedrooms 3
- community
- rental type House
owner badge
- sleeps 7
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$3,000
- $5,000
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
owner badge
- sleeps 8
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$3,500
- $6,000
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
owner badge
- sleeps 8
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$3,800
- $5,500
/wk
- bedrooms 5
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 10
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$1,500
- $1,500
/nt
$10,500 - $10,500 /wk
- bedrooms 2
- community Robbins Rest
- rental type Cottage
owner badge
- sleeps 4
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$1,500
- $3,200
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 8
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$5,000
- $7,500
/wk
- bedrooms 2
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 5
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$2,300
- $2,300
/wk
- bedrooms 5
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 12
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$5,500
- $8,500
/wk
- bedrooms 5
- community Davis Park Assn.
- rental type House
- sleeps 12
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$3,500
- $6,300
/wk
- bedrooms 1
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type Studio
- sleeps 2
- baths 1½
- rates (USD)
$250
- $250
/nt
$1,500 - $1,500 /wk
$5,000 - $6,000 /mth
- bedrooms 4
- community OceanBayPark/Seaview
- rental type House
- sleeps 8
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$2,450
- $7,000
/wk
- bedrooms 1
- community Kismet
- rental type Apartment
- sleeps 4
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$250
- $300
/nt
$1,350 - $1,500 /wk
$5,000 - $5,500 /mth
- bedrooms 3
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 6
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$1,650
- $3,550
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Ocean Beach
- rental type House
- sleeps 8
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$3,000
- $6,500
/wk
$12,000 - $30,000 /mth
- bedrooms 4
- community Ocean Beach
- rental type House
- sleeps 7
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$1,500
- $3,500
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 8
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$2,900
- $5,500
/wk
$10,000 - $20,000 /mth
- bedrooms 4
- community Atlantique
- rental type House
- sleeps 8
- baths 1½
- rates (USD)
$2,150
- $2,750
/wk
- bedrooms 3
- community Lonelyville
- rental type House
- sleeps 6
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$3,000
- $6,600
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Kismet
- rental type House
- sleeps 10
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$350
- $550
/nt
$1,000 - $3,650 /wk
- bedrooms 2
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 7
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$1,500
- $3,800
/wk
- bedrooms 5
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 10
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$1,000
- $1,600
/nt
$5,000 - $10,000 /wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Robbin's Rest
- rental type House
owner badge
- sleeps 10
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$1,500
- $4,500
/wk
- bedrooms 3
- community Atlantique
- rental type House
- sleeps 8
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$250
- $450
/nt
$1,750 - $2,500 /wk
$7,500 - $9,000 /mth
- bedrooms 4
- community
- rental type House
- sleeps 9
- baths 1½
- rates (USD)
$3,000
- $3,000
/wk
$11,000 - $11,000 /mth
- bedrooms 4
- community Ocean Beach
- rental type House
- sleeps 12
- baths 3
- rates (USD)
$1,800
- $5,200
/wk
- bedrooms 1
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type Studio
- sleeps 2
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$100
- $400
/nt
$500 - $2,000 /wk
$1,000 - $6,000 /mth
- bedrooms 3
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type Apartment
- sleeps 6
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$500
- $3,250
/wk
$2,000 - $10,000 /mth
- bedrooms 5
- community OB-Corneille Estates
- rental type House
- sleeps 10
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$4,000
- $5,500
/wk
- bedrooms 2
- community Kismet
- rental type Villa
- sleeps 6
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$150
- $995
/nt
$795 - $5,000 /wk
$2,995 - $20,000 /mth
- bedrooms 3
- community Captree Island
- rental type House
- sleeps 8
- baths 1½
- rates (USD)
$200
- $400
/nt
$1,200 - $2,800 /wk
$4,000 - $10,000 /mth
- bedrooms 4
- community Atlantique
- rental type House
- sleeps 8
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$4,000
- $4,000
/wk
- bedrooms 3
- community
- rental type House
- sleeps 9
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$2,000
- $4,500
/wk
- bedrooms 1
- community
- rental type House
- sleeps 2
- baths 1
- rates (USD)
$3,500
- $3,500
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 8
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$3,700
- $4,500
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Corneille Estates
- rental type House
- sleeps 9
- baths 2½
- rates (USD) $18,000 - $18,000 /mth
- bedrooms 5
- community Ocean Beach
- rental type House
- sleeps 10
- baths 3
- rates (USD)
$1,500
- $8,000
/wk
- bedrooms 3
- community
- rental type House
- sleeps 6
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$3,200
- $3,400
/nt
$3,200 - $3,400 /wk
$10,000 - $10,000 /mth
- bedrooms 5
- community Ocean Bay Park West
- rental type House
- sleeps 10
- baths 3
- rates (USD)
$7,500
- $8,000
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 8
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$2,300
- $3,400
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community DavisPark/OceanRidge
- rental type House
- sleeps 8
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$3,500
- $3,500
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Davis Park
- rental type House
- sleeps 10
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$3,000
- $4,000
/wk
- bedrooms 4
- community Robbins Rest
- rental type House
- sleeps 7
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$1,750
- $2,800
/wk
- bedrooms 2
- community Ocean Bay Park
- rental type Apartment
- sleeps 6
- baths 2
- rates (USD)
$1,000
- $1,400
/wk
$4,000 - $5,000 /mth
- bedrooms 4
- community ocean beach/ seaview
- rental type House
- sleeps 10
- baths 2½
- rates (USD)
$3,000
- $10,000
/wk
$10,000 - $35,000 /mth
- bedrooms 5
- community Robbins Rest
- rental type House
- sleeps 10
- baths 3
- rates (USD)
$1,050
- $1,300
/nt
