Properties in Fire Island average 4.8 out of 5 stars.
1 - 50 of 300+
Additional fees apply.Taxes may be added.

Recent Reviews

  • Great house!
    5 of 5

    Steps away from the beach, well maintained, lots of room, great deck with a new grill, well-equipped kitchen with everything you need to cook for a group, towels, good mattresses, an impressive collection of board games for kids... Highly recommend!

    Stayed: Oct 2018
  • Impeccable home just feet away from the ocean
    5 of 5

    Great long-time friend get-together over a long weekend at Windows on the Sea in Ocean Beach, Fire Island.The house is impeccable and clean. With updated amenities, homeowners Whitney & Anthony have thought of everything and are easily accessible via phone or text. From voice command Alexa, who seems to know all, to the surround sound speakers, which give a musical to the background to this beautifully appointed home. Bikes, beach chairs, umbrellas, leave them all home, because the homeowners have them readily available for you to use. The beach and ocean, which are visible from almost every area of the home, is truly a very short walking distance and the restaurants & shops are a picturesque, easy walk from the house. So happy to have had the pleasure of staying their home. Thank you to Whitney & Anthony for sharing their home with us. You’ve completely surpassed my expectations, Whitney & Anthony...can’t wait to return to Windows on the Sea.

    Stayed: Sep 2018