Additional fees apply.Taxes may be added.

Recent Reviews

  • We loved our rental and the instructions were easy to follow.
    5 of 5

    We had a wonderful stay! The house was very clean and had everything we needed. We would absolutely recommend staying there!

    Stayed: Aug 2018
  • Had a great time for our first and not last visit to Fire Island!
    5 of 5

    Jenny's house is a much-loved family home with some wonderful features. There's a beautiful almost cabin like feel in the living room-kitchen area because of the knotty pine walls, and we appreciated the comfortable couches and bed in the master bedroom — as well as the smart tv, the layout of the kitchen, the air conditioning & heating, washer and dryer, and the spacious outdoor deck. The bedrooms upstairs are nice as well, though we didn't use them, and as seniors wouldn't have wanted to go up and down the steep staircase ourselves to get downstairs to the bathroom. Since it was just two of us, we didn't need to. For a family with kids this would be no problem. The property needs a bit of work — better sliding glass doors that aren't stained and working screen doors — so as to take full advantage of the nice view of and access to the deck. (New sliding doors & screens are, apparently, on order, which is good!) There were two well-used bikes, though it wasn't that easy to get them in and out of the shed. The washer and dryer were great — but the shed in which they were housed could have used more cleaning. In any case, despite these small details, the location was perfect, and Jenny was very helpful when we needed more lightbulbs and a bike lock. What was especially nice was that because we came off-season, she gave us early check-in and late checkout, which truly contributed to our feeling relaxed and welcomed. As noted in the title, we had a great time!

    Stayed: Sep 2018